Fuller Law Firm
408-234-7563
79 Devine Street, Suite 100, San Jose, CA 95110
408-234-7563
Blog
408-234-7563
Mental health evaluations can significantly affect a criminal case. They can influence whether someone is found competent to stand trial. They can also affect whether an insanity defense applies or how a court approaches sentencing. These evaluations often shape the entire direction of a case. Sometimes they matter more than the facts of the alleged crime itself.
If mental health is a factor in your case in 2026, our Alameda County, CA criminal defense lawyer can help you understand how an evaluation might affect your defense options.
A competency evaluation determines whether a defendant understands the criminal charges against them. It also asks whether they can assist in their own defense. Under California Penal Code Section 1368, the court must suspend criminal proceedings when the judge has a doubt about the defendant’s mental competence and begins competency proceedings.
This process is separate from guilt or innocence. It simply asks whether the person can participate meaningfully in their own defense right now. The case doesn't move forward until competency is restored if the person is found incompetent. This often happens through treatment.
A competency evaluation looks at a person's mental state right now, at the time of trial. An insanity defense looks backward instead. It focuses on the defendant's mental state at the time the alleged crime occurred. Under California law, a defendant found not guilty by reason of insanity is not held criminally responsible. This doesn't mean they go free without consequences, though.
These two concepts often get confused. They serve very different purposes in a criminal case. A person can be competent to stand trial while still raising an insanity defense related to their state of mind during the offense itself.
A defendant found not guilty by reason of insanity is typically committed to a state mental health facility rather than released. The length of this commitment can sometimes extend beyond what a prison sentence would have been. This depends on the person's progress and ongoing evaluations.
Mental health evaluations can play an important role during sentencing. This is true even when competency and insanity aren't at issue. Courts often consider a defendant's mental health history when deciding whether to pursue alternative sentencing options. This can include mental health diversion programs instead of traditional incarceration.
California's mental health diversion program was established under Penal Code Section 1001.36. It allows certain defendants with qualifying mental health conditions to receive treatment instead of facing standard prosecution. The charges may be dismissed entirely if the person completes treatment.
Not every mental health condition automatically qualifies a defendant for diversion. Courts generally look for a diagnosed mental disorder that played a significant role in the alleged offense. Common qualifying conditions include:
The court also considers whether the defendant poses an unreasonable risk to public safety. It looks at whether appropriate treatment is available in the community too.
A mental health evaluation typically involves interviews with the defendant. It also includes a review of medical and psychiatric records. Sometimes it involves psychological testing as well. Evaluators may also speak with family members or review past treatment history to build a complete picture of the person's mental health background.
This evidence can be presented in court through expert testimony. Both the prosecution and defense may have their own evaluators offer opinions. The judge or jury then weighs this testimony when making decisions about competency, insanity, or sentencing.
A defense attorney can help identify whether a competency evaluation, insanity defense, or mental health diversion might apply to your case. They can also work with qualified mental health professionals to build supporting evidence. This work can help advocate for treatment-focused outcomes when appropriate, rather than standard prosecution and incarceration.
Our firm is proud to serve the local community, believing that every client and their family deserve a voice within a complex legal system. Often, clients and their families are simply looking for a path back to stability. They want someone who believes in them and will advocate for the best possible outcome.
Contact Fuller Law Firm at 408-234-7563 to talk to our Alameda County criminal defense lawyer today.
408-234-7563From our office in San Jose, California, we serve clients throughout the Bay Area, including but not limited to Campbell, Los Gatos, Cupertino, Santa Clara, Sunnyvale, Gilroy, Morgan Hill, Los Altos, Palo Alto, Saratoga, Milpitas, Mountain View, Fremont, Stanford, Union City, and Santa Clara County.
The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.
I have read and understand the Disclaimer and Privacy Policy.
